← Back to all articles
UK Employment Law

Employment Tribunal Success Rate UK: Payouts

Employment Tribunal Success Rate UK: Payouts

TL;DR: Most UK employment tribunal claims settle long before a hearing, and the ones that do reach judgment pay a median of £6,746 for unfair dismissal against a tail that runs close to £1m for discrimination. This guide chains the official figures together so you can put a number on a dispute before deciding how hard to fight it.

The question a board asks, and the numbers that answer it

A grievance has stopped behaving like a grievance. Legal are involved, the employee has mentioned Acas, and somebody in the room asks the obvious question: what happens if this goes all the way? Usually nobody has a number.

The honest answer is not one success rate. It is a chain of probabilities, because a dispute has to survive several stages before anyone is awarded anything, and most disputes do not survive the first one.

This guide works through four things an HR Director needs in order to price a dispute. How far claims actually travel through the system. What published success rates measure, and what they quietly leave out. What tribunals pay out when they do decide. And the time cost of a claim that nobody settles.

Every figure here comes from the Ministry of Justice, Acas or GOV.UK, with its year attached. Where the official data has a hole in it, the hole is named rather than filled with something that sounds plausible.

How many claims reach a hearing at all

Start with the funnel, because the funnel is where most of the risk disappears.

Acas early conciliation is a compulsory gate. With narrow exceptions, a claimant cannot lodge a tribunal claim without first notifying Acas, so almost every dispute that becomes serious passes through it. That makes the Acas data the widest view anyone has of UK employment disputes.

In April to June 2025, Acas recorded that 68% of early conciliation notifications never became an employment tribunal claim at all. Some were settled through conciliation, others dropped or never seriously pursued. Either way, slightly over two thirds of disputes that reach the gate stop there.

Of the claims that were submitted, 79% did not go on to have a hearing. Acas recorded roughly 74% of those non-hearing outcomes as settled rather than withdrawn, with 3,827 settlements against 1,355 withdrawals in the quarter.

Chain those together and you get the figure the board actually asked for. Of 100 disputes that reach Acas, around 32 become tribunal claims, and around 7 of those reach a hearing. That is an estimate built from one quarter of data, not a published statistic, and the composition of claims shifts between quarters. As an order of magnitude it holds up.

What that does to your posture is significant. "Will we win at a hearing" is a question about the 7%. The question that governs nearly every dispute you will handle is different: at which stage do you want to stop paying for this? Conciliation, pre-hearing settlement and judgment are three different price points, and the first two are where the overwhelming majority of cases are decided.

Source: Acas, Early conciliation and employment tribunal data: April to June 2025.

Success rates by claim type, and what they leave out

Before quoting any success rate to a CFO, check its denominator. Success at hearing, success across all disposals and success across all disputes that reached Acas are three different numbers with the same name, and they can differ by an order of magnitude.

Claim mix gives useful context for where your exposure is likely to sit. In the final quarter of 2025/26, unfair dismissal accounted for 23% of jurisdictional complaint receipts, disability discrimination 16% and unauthorised deductions from wages 13%, so those three categories made up roughly 52% of everything coming in (MOJ, Tribunals Statistics Quarterly: January to March 2026).

Then the uncomfortable part. If you are looking for an employment tribunal success rate for the UK broken down by claim type, there is no official one to quote. The Ministry of Justice publishes receipts and disposals by jurisdiction, and it suspended its award data, but it does not publish a success-at-hearing rate per jurisdiction at a granularity you can use. Any percentage you see attached to unfair dismissal or disability discrimination has been calculated by somebody other than the MOJ, from a different dataset, and that dataset is the problem.

The win rates circulating by claim type come from commercial databases built on published judgments. A published judgment only exists where a case was contested all the way to a reasoned decision. The four in five claims that settled or were withdrawn produce no judgment and therefore appear nowhere in that calculation.

A win rate drawn from published judgments describes the contested minority. It cannot tell you how often employers lose.

The practical effect is a selection bias that runs in a direction most readers miss. Claim types that are essentially arithmetic, such as unpaid wages or holiday pay, get fought to judgment precisely because there is little to negotiate about, so they show high claimant success. That reflects which cases reach a decision, and says little about how strong a wages claim is relative to a discrimination claim.

Two sources of signal are more useful than any published percentage. The first is your own disposal history, because it reflects your own sector and your own documentation standards. The second is reading comparable decisions directly, which the next sections cover.

What a tribunal actually pays out

The anchor figure for unfair dismissal is the median award of £6,746 in 2023/24, across 646 awards. The average for the same year was £13,749.

That gap between median and mean is the first thing to explain to anyone who has only seen a headline. The median is the midpoint, so half of all awards were below £6,746. The average is dragged upward by a small number of very large awards, which means it describes almost nobody's actual case.

Discrimination sits materially higher across the board.

Claim type (2023/24) Median award Average award
Unfair dismissal £6,746 £13,749
Disability discrimination £17,218 £44,483
Sex discrimination £16,161 £53,403
Race discrimination £10,253 £29,532

The tail is what gives boards the wrong intuition. The highest single awards in 2023/24 were £995,128 for sex discrimination and £964,465 for disability discrimination, against £179,124 for unfair dismissal. Figures from the MOJ Employment Tribunal tables for 2023 to 2024.

There is a structural reason for that pattern. For dismissals from 6 April 2026, the compensatory award for ordinary unfair dismissal is capped at £123,543 or 52 weeks' gross pay, whichever is lower, in addition to the basic award. Compensation under the Equality Act 2010 and for whistleblowing carries no cap at all, which is why uncapped discrimination claims hold the million-pound outcomes.

Two cautions before you quote any of these figures. Small bases distort badly: the age discrimination median of £86,349 rests on just 12 awards and should not be treated as typical of anything. And there is no official median award published for breach of contract, so if you see one quoted, it did not come from the MOJ.

Why every average payout figure is from 2023/24

Here is the detail that most "average tribunal payout" pages do not mention. The Ministry of Justice has suspended its annual publication of compensation and costs data awarded by the Employment Tribunal. The suspension is attributed to the HMCTS Reform case management migration and the work of extracting and quality-assuring award data out of the new system.

So the most recent official award dataset is 2023/24, published on 21 October 2024. Every figure in the previous section, and every figure in every competing article on this topic, traces back to that one table (MOJ, Tribunals Statistics Quarterly: April to June 2026).

What staleness means in practice matters more than the fact itself. Those medians predate two years of wage growth, since compensatory awards are largely a function of lost earnings. They also predate the April 2026 uprating of the statutory cap.

There is a further change coming. The unfair dismissal compensatory cap is due to be removed under the Employment Rights Act 2025, reported as taking effect on 1 January 2027. Treat that as pending and verify the position against a primary source before relying on the cap in any settlement discussion.

The sensible adjustment is not a calculation you should attempt yourself. Read the published medians as a floor on current exposure, label them with their year whenever you quote them, and avoid presenting a 2023/24 figure as a 2026 estimate.

The cost nobody prices in: 70,000 open claims

Money is the first currency in a tribunal dispute. Time is the second, and it is the one that rarely appears in a board paper.

In 2025/26 the tribunal received around 50,000 single claims and disposed of around 26,000. Receipts were up 39% year on year while disposals fell 12%, leaving roughly 64,000 single claims open at the end of March 2026 (MOJ, January to March 2026).

It got worse immediately afterwards. The open single-claim caseload rose 51% to around 70,000 by the end of June 2026, the highest on record, with 14,000 claims received and only 6,100 disposed of in that quarter (MOJ, April to June 2026).

Translate that into employer cost. A claim that does not settle holds witness availability open, keeps managers who have usually moved on available to give evidence, accrues legal spend across every interlocutory stage, and leaves an unresolved item on your risk register. A system clearing fewer cases than it receives cannot give you a reliable date for when that ends.

An official current median time from claim to disposal was not available at research time, so this guide does not offer one. The direction of travel is the honest statement: receipts rising, disposals falling, caseload at a record high.

There is also a publication cost that settlement never carries. A decision taken to judgment is published permanently on GOV.UK and cannot be removed under GDPR.

Volume pressure is likely to increase further as qualifying-period reform lands, since the qualifying period drops to six months on 1 January 2027.

How to look up comparable cases yourself

You do not need a paid database to read comparable judgments. The official employment tribunal decisions database on GOV.UK is free, and held 135,314 decisions as at November 2026.

Coverage runs from February 2017 onward for England, Wales and Scotland. Decisions before that are not online, and obtaining them means contacting Norwich Magistrates' Court or Glasgow Tribunals Centre directly.

Four filters do the work: nation, one of 39 jurisdiction codes, a decision date range, and free-text keyword. The keyword field searches the decision text, so it picks up sectors, employer names and specific issues.

For an HR reader, the useful search combines a jurisdiction code with a sector keyword and a recent date range. A disability discrimination code plus "care home" plus the last eighteen months returns reasoned judgments on facts recognisably close to yours, including the remedy decisions, which is where you see how a tribunal actually arrived at a figure.

The sampling caveat applies here too. What you are reading is the contested minority. Use these decisions to understand how tribunals reason and what evidence they find persuasive, rather than as a measure of how often employers lose.

Turning the numbers into a settlement number

Build the view out loud, stage by stage, with the chain from earlier in mind. What is the likelihood this becomes a filed claim rather than ending at conciliation? If filed, what is the likelihood it reaches a hearing? If heard, what award band does this claim type sit in? Then add the internal and legal cost you will pay whatever the outcome, which is irrecoverable in the great majority of tribunal cases.

Run that chain twice, once for a capped unfair dismissal claim and once for an uncapped discrimination claim, and the reason posture matters becomes obvious. A capped unfair dismissal claim sitting against a median around £6,746 is a modest commercial problem. An uncapped discrimination claim with a tail approaching £1m is a different category of decision, even when you think the merits are better.

Some claims should be fought regardless of the arithmetic. A policy point you will face again, a case where settling signals that any grievance can be converted into cash, or an allegation against a manager that you believe to be false and that would stand as a finding if left unanswered.

Other situations make generosity cheap. A short-service dispute where the defence cost comfortably exceeds any plausible award rarely justifies a fight, and the same often applies where the facts are weak and a constructive dismissal allegation would turn on contemporaneous notes nobody made.

What the numbers cannot do is assess your facts. A tribunal award is one component of exposure, alongside costs, management time and a judgment that stays published, and none of this is advice on a specific case. Treat the data as the input to the conversation with your adviser.

What to take into the room

Three things are worth carrying into that meeting. Most disputes end well before a hearing, so the stage at which you choose to stop is the real decision. The official payout figures are two years old and should be read as a floor rather than a current estimate. And the uncapped claim types are where your genuine exposure sits.

Set your posture from the probability-weighted cost. The headline award that made the trade press last month is not your case.

The cheapest intervention of all sits upstream of everything above: clear policy answers, applied consistently, before a question hardens into a grievance.

For readers at the earlier stage of this question, the companion guides on constructive dismissal and discrimination cover whether you have a problem in the first place.

Frequently Asked Questions

What percentage of employment tribunal claims are successful in the UK?

There is no single reliable figure, because most claims never reach a decision. Acas data for April to June 2025 shows that 79% of tribunal claims submitted did not go on to have a hearing, and around 74% of those non-hearing outcomes were recorded as settled. Win rates you may see quoted by claim type are usually derived from published judgments, which only cover cases contested to a reasoned decision and therefore exclude the large majority of claims.

What is the average payout at an employment tribunal?

The most recent official figures cover 2023/24. The median unfair dismissal award was £6,746 against an average of £13,749, while discrimination awards were higher, with a median of £17,218 for disability discrimination. Averages are pulled upward by a small number of very large awards, including £995,128 for sex discrimination in that year. No newer official award data exists, because the Ministry of Justice has suspended publication during its case management system migration.

Do most employment tribunal claims settle before a hearing?

Yes, and most disputes do not even become claims. Acas recorded that 68% of early conciliation notifications in April to June 2025 never progressed to a tribunal claim. Of the claims that were filed, 79% never reached a hearing, and Acas logged roughly three quarters of those outcomes as settled rather than withdrawn.

Can you search employment tribunal cases?

Yes, free of charge on GOV.UK. The employment tribunal decisions database held 135,314 decisions as at November 2026 and covers England, Wales and Scotland from February 2017 onward, with filters for nation, jurisdiction code, decision date and keyword. Decisions before February 2017 require contacting Norwich Magistrates' Court or Glasgow Tribunals Centre. Once published, a decision is permanent and cannot be removed under GDPR.

Is compensation for unfair dismissal capped?

For dismissals from 6 April 2026 the compensatory award for ordinary unfair dismissal is capped at £123,543 or 52 weeks' gross pay, whichever is lower, on top of the basic award. Discrimination claims under the Equality Act 2010 and whistleblowing claims carry no cap, which is why the largest awards cluster there. The Employment Rights Act 2025 is reported to remove the unfair dismissal cap from 1 January 2027, so check the current position before relying on the cap in a settlement discussion.

Aura Editorial
About the author: Aura Editorial

The Aura HR editorial desk. We track employment law and workplace practice across the UK and Europe, and turn it into guidance HR teams can act on.

Ready to Transform Your HR?

Discover how Aura HR's AI-powered solutions can revolutionize your human resources management.

Get Started